Can Arguing Be Good For Your Health?

by Coach Da-Nay Macklin BS, CCLC

Feel free to add share this article...

| More


Coaches Corner with The Conquering Coach

“You Cannot Conquer What You Will Not Confront!”

Judging strictly by feelings, arguing is good for your health if you won the argument and bad for your health if you lost.  The winner has a sense of accomplishment and feels great about the “victory”.  The person who lost is emotionally defeated and angry.  Actually, an argument with a winner and loser is unhealthy for both participants.

Studies have shown that arguing can have serious physical effects.  A study of 3,682 couples discovered that when women gave up and gave in during arguments with their husbands, they risked being four times more likely to die than women who knew how to argue toward a productive result. They also were at risk of developing depression and irritable bowel syndrome, according to the medical journal, Psychosomatic Medicine.   http://www.pbs.org/thisemotionallife/blogs/arguing-intimacy 

Men, on the other hand, chance getting serious health conditions from repeated unproductive arguing. Duke University Medical Center studied men who frequently harbored intense hostility, anger and depression, and found them to be at greater risk of high blood pressure, coronary artery disease and type two diabetes.

Both men and women are, according to the University College London, 1.34 times more likely to experience chest pain, heart attacks and even risk sudden cardiac death from high levels of negativity in their close personal relationships. http://www.creators.com/health/rallie-mcallister-your-health/arguing-with-your-spouse-could-be-hazardous-to-your-health.html

Is there any kind of arguing that is good for you?  Sometimes we feel better after an argument because we finally said what we had been stewing over.  We feel a sense of release because we know that the other person knows where we stand and the ball is now in his court.

But arguing is a lot more than swatting a ball back and forth on a tennis court.  It involves a relationship—spouses, parents to children, friend to friend.  Arguing can either strengthen a relationship or tear it apart.  Arguing is healthy if both parties benefit from the argument.  There should be no winner and loser, no victor and victim.  Healthy arguing allows each person to learn more about the other and to integrate that new knowledge into their relationship.

Arguing lets you discover something you didn’t know about the other person.  Maybe you never realized that your husband hates it when you keep getting up to putter with chores while the two of you are watching TV.  Maybe you learned that your mom and dad worry when you forget to call and let them know where you are.  Or perhaps you found out that the reason your wife doesn’t like you going out with the guys is because her father did it constantly.  Healthy arguing opens your eyes to sensitive areas in the other person.  By adjusting your future words, actions, and attitudes to take these into consideration, you can make your lives together easier. 

icon



 
 

Arguing clears the air.  If you stay focused on the issue instead of attacking the other person, the problem can be addressed and settled without either party feeling attacked.  This kind of healthy arguing deals with the situations that inevitably surface yet protects each person by being logical and problem-oriented instead of emotional and person-oriented.   

Arguing gives you a chance to validate the other person.  The wrong way to argue is to tear down the other person so that you and your argument can rise to the top.  Repeated blows to the other person’s sense of worth could raise the risk that he or she could later become physically ill from the non-stop stress.  You don’t want that on your conscience.  Instead, at the beginning of your argument, and during it, remind the other person of how well he handled similar situations in the past, of his ability to make smart decisions, and any other coping quality he has that relates to the issue so that you are building up his self-esteem while you are pointing out what needs to change.  This lets your arguing partner know that you value him as a person and his right to an opinion while encouraging him to respect your right to disagree.

Stated above we can see that, arguing can be healthy or unhealthy for us.  It all depends on the kind of arguing we are doing.  If we are arguing because we are tired, in a bad mood, annoyed, or just enjoy getting the other person riled up, we will be slinging emotional barbs that will hurt and could cause long-term health issues for that person.  If, on the other hand, we have a serious issue to deal with and approach the argument from the perspective of trying to fix the problem, understanding the other person’s viewpoint, and coming up with a resolution that satisfies both of you, arguing will be a healthy exercise that you both will benefit from. 

 

Finishing an argument with both parties agreeing, or agreeing to disagree, is healthy.  Believe it or not, this kind of arguing:

Reduces blood pressure and the chances of a heart attack

Calms emotions, restoring an atmosphere of peace and flexibility

Decreases cortisol levels (the stress hormone), which contribute to a breakdown of immunity and trigger numerous illnesses

Increases serotonin (a neurotransmitter in our brains) giving us a feeling of happiness and contentment

Deepens our relationship with our family member or friend by letting us understand the reasons behind that person’s behavior and attitude.

So, arguing is good for our health if we argue the right way—dealing with the problem and not attacking the person.  Arguing with our emotions up front, and our logic and common sense left behind sets the stage for an emotional showdown that accomplishes nothing. It damages the other person and hurts us as well.  We will probably feel a little guilty, which if we ignore, makes us more cynical and less able to empathize the next time around.

Should we argue?  Yes!  Arguing is a natural part of life and relationships.  If done without anger, we can discover what the other person is really thinking, where he or she stands on an issue, express our own opinion, and come up with a solution that we both can agree on.   Both the process of arguing and the resolution are health-promoting activities that everyone should engage in on a semi-regular basis.  So, argue—to your health!

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y281/irw2003/CelestineChua.jpg
Written by Da-Nay Macklin; Da-Nay Macklin BS, CCLC has chosen her passion over everything else when she left behind several Fortune 100 companies.  Today, as a certified life coach she enables thousands to achieve their goals and life purpose through her personal development blog and coaching: www.danaymacklin.com.

 


Here is your opportunity to stop hating the media and actually become it!

We are always looking for additional people to submit stories, scores, stats, photos, video, etc...

NOTE: We are proud to announce that for the entire month of October, S.C. Fitch Enterprises, and all of its affiliates including Amateur Sports News Network, ASNN365.com, Amateur Sports Gallery and Kennel Sports Talk will be honoring and donating a portion of our online proceeds to American Cancer Society. Click here to make a donation.
 


FOLLOW US...

HTML Comment Box is loading comments...